Case Study 1 - Outnumbered

Case Study : Outnumbered

Outnumbered is a successful British Situation Comedy (Sitcom) named so simply because the two parental central protagonists, 'Sue' and 'Pete' are outnumbered by their three children. It is set in West London and although on the surface offers pluralistic representations in the guise of their unruly children who often intellectually challenge their parents, it very much follows a standard genre template established by family based Sitcoms like Butterflies and My Family. There are regular and transitory characters, unseen characters (a common convention) e.g. Sue's boss and takes place primarily in domestic locations. It has received academic criticism for failing to address changing representations in gender and family within society by maintaining conventional representations; they are a nuclear family (a statistically declining unit) while Pete is a History teacher and Sue is a part-time PA, again promoting gender cultural stereotypes.
____________________________________________________________________________


Broadcast & Production Details

Broadcast Network : BBC (PSB)
Broadcast Channel : BBC1
Production Company : Hat Trick Productions
Written, Directed & Produced By : Andy Hamilton & Guy Jenkins
Semi-Scripted / Part Improvised Format
5 Series (2007, 2008, 2010, 2011, 2014)
Running Time : 30 Minutes

Production Company Ident


Hat Trick Productions Back Catalogue of Success

Drop the Dead Donkey (C4, 1990-1998)
Father Ted (C4, 1995-1998)
Have I Got News For You (BBC2, 1990-2000 & BBC1 2000-present)
Room 101 (BBC2, 1994-2007 & BBC1, 2012-present)
The Kumars at No. 42 (BBC2, 2001-2004 & BBC1, 2005-2006)
Whose Line Is It Anyway (C4, 1988-1998)

______________________________________________________________________________


Institution & Channel Brand Identity


The BBC is a Public Service Broadcaster (PSB) and the world's oldest national broadcasting organisation. It is established under a Royal Charter and operates under an agreement with the Secretary of State for Culture, Media & Sport. It is funded by an annual television licence fee. The focus for a PSB is not making money (like commercial broadcasters such as ITV or SKY who make money from advertising) but to inform and educate the public, making us all into better people. PSBs have rules that they have to follow (which the others don't) including;
  • Must make quality programmes
  • Must have a proportion of British-made programmes
  • Must reflect the diversity of Britain (religions, nations, etc)
  • A proportion of programmes must be made outside the M25
  • Must have certain genres of programmes (news, etc)
  • Must show a balanced mix of genres (no stripped schedules with repeated showings of the same programme).
Ofcom, the regulator, is worried that PSBs such as the BBC and Channel 4 will not survive in the age of digital TV (see VOD below) as other broadcasters can drop unpopular genres and import cheap American programmes in an attempt to increase profits (not an option for PSBs).





Outnumbered follows on from a historical back catalogue of successful BBC produced and commissioned sitcoms. On BBC1 these include;

Fawlty Towers
The Good Life
Yes Minister
One Foot in the Grave
Keeping Up Appearances
Only Fools & Horses
Vicar of Dibley
My Family
Gavin & Stacey

Outnumbered was commissioned by the BBC from Hat Track Productions, an independent production company (see above). It fits well with the BBC1's reputation for broadcasting non-challenging, mainstream sitcoms (it represents safe genre programming) which focus on stereotypical representations (E.g. Ben Harper in My Family & Hyacinth Bucket in Keeping Up Appearances). In the industry, and in contrast to BBC1, C4 have a reputation for broadcasting more challenging sitcoms (see Hat Track list above).

Mainstream sitcoms are welcomed by the BBC as they have limited production values (making them cheaper to produce) and are often based on a simple idea that can be easily marketed to a mass audience.

_____________________________________________________________________________


Characters

You must first establish who the characters are. Use the link below to access a character guide. You must be able to identify something about each character that will have audience appeal (question 4b).

For example;
"Pete Brockman is played by Hugh Dennis, a comedic actor who has 'star appeal' (Richard Dyer) from appearing in the successful BBC comedy quiz/panel/stand-up hybrid show Mock The Week."
What is it about the other main characters that an audience may find appealing? Samantha Bond, playing Aunt Angela, is probably the biggest 'star' to appear in the show; she played Miss Moneypenny in some of the Bond films.

_____________________________________________________________________________


Scheduling & Target Audience (Question 4a - 15 marks)
  • Series 1 : BBC1 broadcast all 6 episodes over a 2 week period, post-watershed & post-primetime (10.35pm), in August 2007. This strategy is called 'event programming' and was used as an experimental marketing strategy; giving the BBC an opportunity to create audience familiarity with the show and characters through repetition before reverting back to a more conventional weekly broadcast for future series. (Audience familiarity is an important audience pleasure)
  • Series 2-5 : Broadcast weekly on BBC1 in a late primetime slot, always after the watershed. Each series (not episode) broadcast on a different day of the week (see below).
  • This post-watershed scheduling suggests some adult themes that are inappropriate for young children. Later series were broadcast slightly earlier to reflect growing popularity (but always after the watershed).
  • BBC resisted the temptation to broadcast Outnumbered during a peak primetime slot (7pm to 8.30pm) as they were aware that Outnumbered required more primary audience involvement than secondary audience involvement in order to fully understand the humour, dialogue and relationships between the characters (the audience really have to concentrate!). Unlike other situation comedies (sitcoms), Outnumbered has no canned laughter soundtrack which is normally used to direct more passive audiences towards the nature of the humour as part of a shared response experience (you can find them funny without giving them your full concentration). This suggests are more niche target audience, perhaps a consequence of the more limited appeal of the semi-improvised, unconventional sitcom format. This suggests that the BBC targeted a more educated, middle class audience (B & C1 according to socio-economic grouping)
  • The target audience widens when you take into consideration the conventional representation of family in Outnumbered and BBC1 channel loyalty research (which suggests a primarily female audience with a significant secondary male audience, middle class, 25-55, educated, urban and city living).
  • Outnumbered has been syndicated to Gold (see below). This is an example of Strip Programming as Outnumbered is shown at the same time Mon-Fri on Gold & Gold+1. It is scheduled at a slightly earlier time than the original broadcasts as Gold is a niche channel focusing on classic comedies with a specific target audience (BBC1 has to broadcast programmes with wider audience appeal in this valuable primetime time slot, e.g. Eastenders). 
Outnumbered is now syndicated to Gold who have adopted a strip scheduling strategy (on at the same time everyday)

When originally broadcast on BBC1, each series of Outnumbered was scheduled on a different day of the week. Examine the table below and try to explain the inconsistency of the scheduling over the years. What was the channel controller thinking?


  • You could focus on the changing scheduling strategy employed over series 1, 2 & 3 (2007, 2008 & 2010). Series 1 represents an example of 'Event Programming' over a 2 week period in an attempt to quickly build a loyal fan base through the repetition of familiar audience pleasures (getting to know characters the target audience can relate to). Series 2 is 'hammocked' between flagship programmes during a late Primetime slot on a Saturday evening in order to attract a wider audience (building on the established fan base). However, the strategy for series 2 wasn't successful and ratings dropped, so series 3 was scheduled on a Thursday evening (one of BBC1's 'comedy zones' in 2010), immediately following BBC's flagship comedy panel show Have I Got New For You (HIGNFY), which had a similar target audience, This is an 'inheritance' strategy (hoping Outnumbered inherits an audience from a popular programme). There were no promotional trailers in-between the programmes either and this is called 'hotswitching' (going straight from one popular programme to a less popular programme without a break of any kind).
For more information & definitions of scheduling / programming strategies see here or here.

Here is an extract from a 2008 TV listing for BBC1 on a Saturday night;
In 2008, Outnumbered was 'hammocked' between SCD Results Show & BBC News (both flagship shows) on a Saturday night. However, competition with X-Factor Results Show on ITV lead to a drop in ratings.
In 2010, the BBC used a 'hotswitching' strategy, scheduling Outnumbered straight after one of its flagship comedy programmes during the Thursday 'comedy zone' slot.

Other Formats, Platforms & Technology

These platforms challenge the conventions of scheduling and broadcasting and should be considered towards the end of your answer. Here are some other ways of consuming Outnumbered;
  • SYNDICATED : On Gold. Every weekday, 8.20pm. Stripped scheduling.
  • VIDEO ON DEMAND (VOD) : On Netflix. Subscription model VOD. All 5 series.
  • CATCH-UP TV: BBC iPlayer is an example. Not currently available but was during series 4 & 5 broadcasts and impacted on overnight audience share stats.
  • iTUNES : Pay-per-download media library. Older series are cheaper than series 5.

____________________________________________________________________________


Audience Appeal / Pleasures (Question 4b - 15 marks)

When answering this question, it is important to give specific examples from specific episodes to support your points!

Here is a basic list of some audience pleasures for Outnumbered. Some of these will be explored in more detail later.
  • Documentary style (fly-on-the-wall production values & use of semi-improvised dialogue giving the series some verisimilitude; a sense of being true & real)
  • Star appeal of Hugh Dennis (Dyer, 1998)
  • Representation of a nuclear family unit (as loving but chaotic)
  • Narrative resolution
  • Schadenfreude (pleasure derived from someone else's misfortune)
  • Audience familiarity with a small cast
  • Short episodes (30 minutes)
  • Recognisable stereotypes (teacher, mother, naughty child, etc)
  • Exaggerated situations (they become amplified to the point of ridiculous)
  • Challenges some sitcom conventions; lack of opening title sequence, no canned laughter soundtrack, no catchphrases, etc).

To score well in the exam (and in the time you will have available) you must present 3 strong points with specific examples from episodes of your case study. I suggest the following 3 points;

1) The documentary fly-on-the-wall style will appeal to the educated middle class target audience who are traditionally the target audience for PSB TV documentaries too. Fly-on-the-wall documentary style production values often include hand-held camera shots and a lack of soundtrack (underscore), focusing instead on the dialogue of the subjects. These techniques are established straight away, in the first episode of series 1 'The School Run', when Pete, the father, and Ben, the younger son who infamously tells lies, argue over a drill.  The slightly shaky hand-held camerawork is used to represent the 'realtime' chaos of the situation, just like an observational documentary, and the semi-improvised dialogue provides a sense of verisimilitude (the appearance of being true or real). Outnumbered challenges many other sitcom conventions too. The lack of a lighthearted opening title sequence, the avoidance of catchphrases and the lack of a canned laughter soundtrack (a normal sitcom convention used to signpost humorous events in mainstream comedies) all lend themselves to the targeting of a more educated, sophisticated and documentary-watching middle class audience. These documentary production values give the series a sense of realism (verisimilitude), providing the audience with pleasurably feelings of familiarity & empathy.

2) Feelings of schadenfreude is another audience pleasure (taking pleasure from someone else's misfortune).  The target audience enjoys seeing events go wrong for Pete and Sue, the parents outnumbered by their three unruly children. The source of these feelings may be the subconscious relief felt that the misfortune is happening to someone else; positioning the audience as superior to the characters. This is likely to be especially true when the target audience is able to identify so closely to the familiar stereotypical representations of family. The recognition of this loving but chaotic family environment is likely to enhance feelings of schadenfreude with the audience recognising themselves as, hopefully, better parents, husbands or wives than those represented in the programme. Episode 3 of series 2, The Old-Fashioned Sunday, illustrates this clearly as Pete and Sue ban television in an attempt facilitate a traditional "family Sunday" with board games and a family walk. As their  attempts to realise this traditional vision of a stereotypical family-centred Sunday fail and arguments between the children persist, they relent and let the children go back to watching the television, exposing themselves as weak parents with little control over their children.  

3) Narrative resolution provides a further audience pleasure. Unlike soap operas where audiences are left frustrated with a 'cliffhanger' as part of an open narrative, sitcom narratives tend to resolve at the end of each episode. This means that individual episodes can be enjoyed in isolation by a secondary audience. However, the lack of an obvious three-act narrative structure in Outnumbered suggests humour that is more sophisticated and subtle, relying on observation and dialogue and less on memorable 'events' and jokes that provide 'belly laughs'. Therefore, it is more difficult to recall memorable single episodes in the same way that it is for Friends (The One With The Male Nanny), Fawlty Towers (The Germans) or Only Fools & Horses (Chandelier or Falling Through The Bar). However, each 30-minute episode sails gently towards a satisfying resolution that provides the audience with most of the answers and leaves few remaining questions, (There are one or two reoccurring themes, such as Ben's lying in series 1). The desire not to end the episode, or go to bed, with unresolved issues represents a shared audience desire.  In Episode 6 of Series 5 (no title), most of the issues raised at the start are resolved within the 30 minute episode; Sue's sister arrives from abroad at the start and leaves before the end, Karen's hamster is lost at the start and found at the end and Ben is seen to overcome his stage fright when the episode concludes with extracts of his performance in 'Spartacus the Musical'. Only the narrative references to Sue's dad's ongoing illness are left unresolved to continue in future episodes; this has been a narrative theme over many series.


____________________________________________________________________________

Other Useful Links